Two silica grades can look similar on a data sheet and behave very differently in a coating. The only reliable way to know which one gives you more matte per kilogram is to measure matting efficiency yourself, in your binder, at your film build. This guide sets out a repeatable method for comparing silica matting agents so that the numbers you collect actually support a purchasing or reformulation decision.
What matting efficiency silica comparisons should measure
Matting efficiency is easiest to define as the amount of matting agent needed to reach a target gloss in a defined system. A grade that reaches 30 GU at 60° with less addition is the more efficient grade in that system. Two related figures are also useful:
- Loading at target gloss – the percentage (on total formulation or on binder solids) needed to hit your specification.
- Gloss reduction per percent added – the slope of the gloss curve around your working point, which tells you how sensitive the finish will be to small weighing or dispersion variations.
Efficiency is not a fixed property of the powder. It depends on film thickness, binder shrinkage, solvent release, cure and dispersion. That is why a supplier's data sheet can guide a shortlist but cannot replace a ladder study in your own formulation.
Set up a fair test before you weigh anything
Most misleading comparisons come from uncontrolled variables rather than from the silica. Before the first panel, fix the following and write them down:
- Base formulation. One batch of unmatted base, split into portions, so every grade sees the same resin, solvent and additive package.
- Dispersion method. Same equipment, tip speed, time and batch size for every sample. Under-dispersed silica leaves agglomerates that matt strongly but look rough; over-dispersed silica can lose efficiency. Record fineness of grind for each sample so you can spot outliers.
- Film build. Apply with a fixed-gap applicator or the production method, and measure dry film thickness. Matting depends heavily on the ratio of particle size to film thickness, so a few microns of difference can move gloss noticeably.
- Substrate. Use the same substrate throughout, ideally a sealed black chart or the real substrate, so absorption does not change the surface.
- Flash-off and cure. Same temperature, humidity, time and (for UV systems) lamp dose. Shrinkage during drying is what pushes particles to the surface; change the cure and you change the result.
Build a loading ladder for each grade
A single loading tells you almost nothing, because two grades can cross over: one may matt faster at low addition while the other reaches a lower floor. Instead, make a ladder of three to five loadings per grade that brackets your target gloss. A typical approach is to run a quick range-finder at one loading, then choose the ladder steps so that at least one point falls above and one below the specification.
Measure gloss according to a recognised method (ISO 2813 or ASTM D523 are the usual references) and take several readings per panel in different positions. Report the mean and the spread; a wide spread is itself a finding, often pointing to uneven film build or poor dispersion.
Choose the right geometry
- 60° is the standard reading for most satin and matte work.
- 85° becomes important below about 10 GU at 60°, where the 60° reading compresses and differences between grades are hard to see. It also captures sheen, the grazing-angle shine that customers notice on deep-matte surfaces.
- 20° is mainly useful for semi-gloss targets.
For deep-matte specifications, record both 60° and 85°. A grade that wins at 60° but leaves high sheen may still fail the visual assessment.
Read efficiency at matched gloss, not matched loading
Plot gloss against loading for each grade and draw a smooth curve through the points. Then read off the loading each grade needs to reach your target. This interpolated number is the fair efficiency comparison. Comparing gloss at one equal loading tends to favour whichever grade happens to be on the steep part of its curve at that point.
Once you know each grade's loading at target, go back to that loading and record the properties that matter for production:
- Viscosity, both fresh and after storage.
- Clarity or haze in clear coats, ideally assessed over a dark substrate.
- Settling and how easily any sediment redisperses.
- Surface feel, scratch or burnish resistance and recoatability, where relevant.
The most efficient grade on paper is only the best grade if these properties are acceptable at the loading it needs.
Use the data sheet to interpret the results
Data sheet values help explain why one grade is more efficient than another and where to look next. On the Vistamatt technical data sheets, each grade lists particle size, BET surface area, oil absorption and pore volume:
- Particle size sets the starting point. Larger particles generally give more matting at a given loading but need sufficient film build. In the industrial range, VS171S (7.0–7.5 µm) and the coarser C-series grades VS381C (8.0–8.3 µm) and VS391C (9.0–9.5 µm) are positioned for higher film builds, while grades such as VS321A (2.1–2.4 µm) suit thin leather finishes.
- Pore volume converts weight into particle volume. Within the range it runs from 1.2–1.5 mL/g up to 1.6–1.9 mL/g; at similar particle size, higher pore volume usually means more particles per gram.
- Oil absorption (DBP, mL/100 g) gives an early warning on viscosity impact at the loading you end up using.
- Loss on ignition broadly reflects surface treatment: compare VS651 (4.48%) with VS6550 (10.55%) in the waterborne range, which share similar particle size and pore volume ranges.
When two grades with similar particle size give different efficiency in your test, these values usually explain it. When they do not, look at dispersion and film build again before drawing conclusions.
Normalise for cost and process, not just weight
Efficiency per kilogram is a technical figure; the commercial decision needs a few more conversions:
- Cost in use. Multiply the loading at target gloss by the delivered price of each grade. A more efficient grade can justify a higher price per kilogram, and the reverse is also true.
- Process cost. If one grade needs longer dispersion or extra rheology control to manage viscosity, include that.
- Robustness. A grade whose gloss curve is flatter around the target is more forgiving of weighing and film-build variation in production, which can matter more than a small efficiency gain.
Common pitfalls when comparing silica grades
- Measuring too early. Gloss can continue to change while solvent leaves and the film finishes curing. Measure at a fixed age, and check again later if your system is slow-curing.
- Comparing across systems. Results in a solvent-borne PU do not transfer directly to a waterborne acrylic or a UV-curable coating, because shrinkage behaviour is different.
- Ignoring batch variation. If possible, test more than one lot of the shortlisted grade before approval, and compare the certificates of analysis against the specification ranges.
- Replacing like-for-like on loading. When switching from an incumbent grade, re-run the ladder rather than substituting at the same percentage. Our TS 100 alternative page shows how a suggested starting grade is set up for that kind of trial.
A simple reporting template
To make comparisons reusable, record the same fields for every grade: base formulation reference, dispersion conditions, fineness of grind, wet and dry film thickness, cure conditions, gloss at each loading and geometry, interpolated loading at target, viscosity at that loading, clarity and settling notes. Kept consistently, this table lets you compare a new candidate against previous trials without repeating the whole study.
If you are starting a comparison, the grade selector narrows the field by application, and we can supply samples of the grades you shortlist so you can run the ladder in your own system.