Untreated Silica Matting Agents: Where Simplicity and Efficiency Win
An untreated silica matting agent has no organic layer to migrate, interfere with cure or weaken recoat adhesion, and its full pore structure works on gloss. Here is where that simplicity pays, what it costs in handling, and how to qualify one.
An untreated silica matting agent is synthetic amorphous silica supplied as made: milled and classified to a controlled particle size, but without a wax or organic after-treatment on the particle surface. It is the oldest and simplest form of silica matting, and it remains the default baseline in many industrial, coil and thin-film systems. This article looks at untreated silica on its own terms: why its simplicity is often an advantage, where its known weaknesses show up, how to recognise it on a datasheet, and how to qualify one without surprises.
What “untreated” means in practice
Every silica matting agent starts as a porous particle whose surface is covered in silanol (Si–OH) groups. Treated grades have part of that surface covered by wax or another organic layer. An untreated grade leaves the silanol surface exposed. Two practical things follow from that:
- The whole particle works on gloss. Matting comes from particles near the surface of the drying film creating micro-roughness that scatters light. With no coating occupying the pores or the surface, the particle structure set by the manufacturing process is what you get.
- The surface is chemically active. Free silanols interact with each other, with water and with polar parts of the formulation. That is the source of untreated silica’s thickening effect and of its tendency to settle firmly.
Neither point is good or bad by itself. Whether untreated silica is the right choice depends on which of these effects your system can use and which it has to manage. For a side-by-side view of how treatment shifts this balance, see the earlier article on wax-treated versus untreated silica; this piece focuses on the untreated side.
Where an untreated silica matting agent wins
Matting efficiency per unit added
Because there is no organic layer, an untreated grade tends to reach a given gloss with a predictable loading for its particle size and pore volume. In thick-film and high-build systems, coarser particles reach a lower gloss at lower loading, which keeps the silica content, and its effect on mechanical properties, under control.
No wax at the surface
Wax that ends up at the film surface can reduce the adhesion of a following coat. Where a finish is sanded and recoated, or is one layer of a multi-coat build, an untreated grade removes that variable. The same applies to systems with sensitive cure chemistry, where it is simpler not to introduce an extra organic component.
Rheology you can use
The thickening effect of untreated silica is often treated as a cost, but in some formulations it helps: a little extra low-shear viscosity can support sag resistance on vertical surfaces. The point is to know it is there and to design the additive package around it, not to be surprised by it at scale-up.
A cleaner baseline for troubleshooting
With fewer variables in the matting agent, it is easier to attribute a defect to dispersion, film build or cure. Many formulators start a new system with an untreated grade precisely so that, if a treated grade is needed later, the reason is clear.
What untreated silica asks of the formulator
The trade-offs are well known and manageable if they are planned for:
- Settling. Untreated particles can form a firm sediment in storage. Anti-settling additives, adequate viscosity and a storage test at elevated temperature are the usual checks.
- Viscosity build. In high-solids and 100 % solids systems there may be little headroom. Read oil absorption and pore volume before choosing the grade, and check viscosity at the dosage you actually need for the gloss target.
- Burnish and mar. Without wax at the surface, burnish resistance depends more on the binder and the slip and mar package. Test it if the finish will be handled, stacked or rubbed.
- Moisture. A high-surface-area silica picks up water from the air. Keep bags sealed, dry and off the floor; excess moisture is a common cause of agglomeration and hard-packing.
Reading a datasheet for treatment level
Few datasheets describe surface chemistry directly, but loss on ignition (LOI) gives a useful signal. Calcination burns off bound organics, so on the Vistamatt technical data sheets a higher LOI indicates a more heavily treated surface. Grades cluster around 4.4–4.6 % LOI, for example VS171S (4.37 %), VS391C (4.50 %) and VS131A (4.4 %), while others sit well above that: VS660 at 8.25 %, VS1650A at 10.46 % and VS6907 at 14.35 %.
LOI also includes bound water and other volatiles, so treat it as an indicator rather than a measurement of treatment. If untreated status matters to your system, for instance because of recoat adhesion, ask for it to be confirmed in writing for the specific grade. Then read the structure figures alongside it: particle size, BET surface area, oil absorption and pore volume still predict most of the matting efficiency and viscosity effect.
Matching an untreated incumbent
Many formulations were built around an untreated imported grade, and the cross-reference pages give a starting point when looking for a second source:
- TS 100, listed as an untreated fumed/thermal silica, is cross-referenced to VS171S (7.0–7.5 µm) for industrial and metal coatings; the TS 100 alternative page places both on an untreated route.
- Grade 621 / 622, listed as untreated with large particle size, is matched on the coarse route to VS391C (9.0–9.5 µm) for thick-film industrial systems.
- C 803, listed as untreated, fine particle and high porosity, is matched on the fine route to VS131A (3.2–3.5 µm) for leather and synthetic leather finishes.
These matches are built on published particle-size data and application, not on a claim that two products are identical. Qualification is always done at matched gloss in your own formulation.
Where VS660 fits
VS660 (5.0–5.3 µm, BET 250–280 m²/g, oil absorption 280–300 mL/100 g, pore volume 1.6–1.8 mL/g) is the lead grade for waterborne clear wood topcoats, with a usual starting dosage of 2–4 % on total formulation. Its LOI of 8.25 % sits above the low-LOI cluster, and the waterborne range is described on the TDS as optimised for high-clarity clear coats with easy dispersibility in waterborne acrylic and PU systems. In other words, VS660 is the reference to screen against when clarity in a waterborne clear is the brief, not an example of an untreated grade. If you are deciding between an untreated route and this waterborne route, run both in the same round and let clarity on a dark substrate decide.
How to screen an untreated grade
- Fix the process. Hold dispersion energy and time, film build and cure constant so the grade is the only variable.
- Bracket the loading. Run three loadings around the expected dosage and interpolate to your gloss target, rather than comparing at equal dosage.
- Compare at matched gloss. Check viscosity, sag, clarity on a dark panel, feel and burnish resistance against your current control.
- Test storage. Look at settling and redispersion after storage before you sign off; this is where untreated grades most often need support from the additive package.
- Check recoat. If the finish is part of a multi-coat build, sand and recoat as part of the round.
Where to start
Choose an untreated silica matting agent when matting efficiency, recoat safety and a simple, well-understood formulation matter most, and plan for settling and viscosity from the beginning. Choose a treated grade when the real problem is settling, burnish, feel or viscosity headroom. Compare candidates in the grade selector, or send your resin system, target gloss, application method and film build through the contact page and Vistamatt will propose grades and a starting dosage for a first screening round, with free 200–500 g samples.